Full iPhone 4 'Antennagate' Q&A Video Surfaces After 16 Years - MacRumorsOpen MenuShow RoundupsShow Forums menuVisit ForumsOpen Sidebar
Skip to Content

Full iPhone 4 'Antennagate' Q&A Video Surfaces After 16 Years

A 47-minute video of the Q&A session from Apple's 2010 iPhone 4 "antennagate" press conference has surfaced on YouTube, showing Steve Jobs, Tim Cook, and Bob Mansfield answering reporters' questions.

Watch on YouTube

The recording was highlighted by Daring Fireball's John Gruber, who attended the event. Apple called the July 16, 2010 press conference amid complaints that holding the iPhone 4 in a particular way could reduce its cellular signal.

Jobs used his prepared presentation to announce free cases for eligible customers and a 30-day return option. Apple later posted video of that presentation, but left out the Q&A, which was documented at the time through written reports and photographs.

Among the exchanges now visible is a question from Gruber at about 18:45 asking whether the three executives used cases on their own iPhone 4s. Jobs, Cook, and Mansfield each hold up an uncased phone. Jobs later gives a lengthy answer about what Apple learned from the controversy, including why the company waited to gather more data before holding the press conference.

Near the end of the recording, Jobs explains Apple's strategy of owning or controlling the core technology behind its products, and why the growing importance of software made that approach valuable for consumer electronics. Gruber says he does not know where the recording came from or why it has surfaced only now.

Popular Stories

iPhone Ultra Fold Feature

Foldable iPhone Development History and Price Revealed in New Report

Tuesday September 8, 2026 5:55 am PDT by
Former Apple CEO Tim Cook played a major role in the development of the foldable iPhone, which could reach around $3,000 with storage upgrades, according to new details shared by Bloomberg's Mark Gurman. Early in the development of the foldable iPhone, the company reportedly targeted a starting retail price of $1,999, hoping to come under the "potentially controversial $2,000 barrier." The...
Tim Cook Apple Logo

Tim Cook Won't Appear in Apple's September 9 Event Video

Monday September 7, 2026 2:27 am PDT by
Tim Cook will attend the screening for Apple's "Surprise and Shine" event this Wednesday, but he will not feature in the event video itself, according to sources cited by Bloomberg's Mark Gurman. Cook stepped down as Apple CEO on September 1 to become executive chairman of the company, paving the way for John Ternus to take over the top job. In his latest Power On newsletter, Gurman said that...
Tim Cook Executive Chair 16x9 1

Tim Cook to Attend White House State Dinner for Xi Jinping

Wednesday September 16, 2026 4:41 pm PDT by
Apple executive chairman Tim Cook is expected to attend a White House state dinner for Chinese President Xi Jinping, reports Bloomberg. Cook stepped down as Apple CEO and transitioned to executive chairman on September 1, with John Ternus taking over. Part of Cook's new role includes engaging with policymakers around the world. U.S. President Donald Trump invited Cook, OpenAI CEO Sam...

Top Rated Comments

1 week ago

I remember this pretty clearly. The issue was that Consumer Reports did a video showing how if you so much as touch the gap between the two antennas, then the cell reception drops to zero immediately every time. It was NOT about "attenuation" which happens when your entire hand covers much of the phone, causing the signal to have trouble going through your hand and dropping by a bar or two.
Memory is a funny thing; that's not what Consumer Reports found:


"Our tests found that when your finger or hand touches a spot on the phone's lower left side—an easy thing to do—the signal can significantly degrade enough to cause you to lose your connection altogether if you're in an area with a weak signal." (emphasis added).
That's "attenuation". Attenuation simply means a reduction in signal strength; it does not mean RF energy being absorbed by a person's entire hand. It is "attenuation" if you go from some bars to no bars or have a slight reduction in signal.

In cases where you had a weak signal (see below for more on this) the signal could appear to drop to 0 and in some cases drop a call, but it wasn't every time in every situation. CR even called it a "reception glitch", which is maybe a mild way of putting it.

https://www.consumerreports.org/cro/news/2010/07/why-apple-mdash-and-not-its-customers-mdash-should-fix-the-iphone-4/index.htm

Yes, the iPhone 4's antenna was designed poorly for certain circumstances (signal was generally great otherwise compared to other smartphones of the day) and Apple's response wasn't ideal, but the effects were not "if you so much as touch the gap between the two antennas, then the cell reception drops to zero immediately every time."

Also, if you want a deeper dive, Anandtech had a thorough analysis of the antenna and signals: https://web.archive.org/web/20100722093919/http://www.anandtech.com/show/3794/the-iphone-4-review/2

Here's part of the review:


"However, in locales that have less signal, but where iOS still displays 5 bars, the drop of 24 dB is visualized much differently. For example, at another test location, signal without holding the phone is -89 dBm, which is still displayed as 5 bars. Cup the phone, and you'll fall all the way to -113 dBm. All the bars dramatically disappear one after the other, people think they've dramatically lost all the signal, and you know the rest.

If you're at 4 bars already, (which puts you on the low end of possible signal strengths), cupping the phone even more delicately is enough to push you the remaining 10 or so dB to cutoff. It doesn't take much when you're at 4 bars, which is why the visualization is flawed. Complicating matters is that signal is completely fine until down around 2 bars at -107 dBm."
One last comment on this. While Apple was deflecting and this was not the only issue, their claim about the phone incorrectly displaying signal strength was accurate and part of the issue, as Anandtech pointed out: https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2010/07/02Letter-from-Apple-Regarding-iPhone-4

This means that people thought their signal was dropping dramatically but the reality was they were typically going from weak signal to less or no signal.
Score: 28 Votes (Like | Disagree)
1 week ago
I miss Steve
Score: 19 Votes (Like | Disagree)
1 week ago
A youtube channel with a bunch of lost Apple content being called “Sir Mix-A-Lot Rare Music” is hilarious.
Score: 19 Votes (Like | Disagree)
btrach144 Avatar
1 week ago

He was very annoyed he had to do this since he was on vacation and had to break it, according to his book.
Kind of sucks big time when you consider he resigned 11 months later due to poor health and died less than 2 months after that. This might have been one of his last chances to vacation with semi-good health. His last chance to spend quality time with his family.

So it's much deeper than just having to cut your vacation short.
Score: 18 Votes (Like | Disagree)
ghostface147 Avatar
1 week ago
He was very annoyed he had to do this since he was on vacation and had to break it, according to his book.
Score: 14 Votes (Like | Disagree)
1 week ago
Somewhat related comment.

What's interesting about this is that while the antenna design was sub-optimal (bridging the gap with a finger could cause a substantial signal drop) and Apple's response was inelegant, instructions about how to hold a phone without interfering with its antenna were common at the time.

For example, the Nokia 6230: "Use only in the normal position. Don't touch the antenna unnecessarily."

and: "Not touching the antenna area during a phone call optimises the antenna performance and the talktime of your phone."

https://manualzilla.com/doc/7271356/nokia-6230-cell-phone-user-manual

For years cell phone manuals told people not to hold their phones in a way that interfered with the antenna. Again, that's not saying the iPhone 4 antenna was designed well for every use situation, but Apple was certainly not the only manufacturer explaining how to hold phones.
Score: 12 Votes (Like | Disagree)
Latest Stories
New 'AirFly Drive' Accessory Turns Wired CarPlay Into Wireless CarPlay
New 'AirFly Drive' Accessory Turns Wired CarPlay Into Wireless CarPlay
1 hour ago
Apple Shares Photos Shot on iPhone Duo
Apple Shares Photos Shot on iPhone Duo
3 hours ago
Apple Says iPhone Duo Has Replaceable 'Cover Layer' Above the Display
Apple Says iPhone Duo Has Replaceable 'Cover Layer' Above the Display
4 hours ago
Apple's Smart Home Camera Will Apparently Have 'No Video Recording'
Apple's Smart Home Camera Will Apparently Have 'No Video Recording'
5 hours ago
Apple TV Just Updated Its Selection of 'Bonus' Movies
Apple TV Just Updated Its Selection of 'Bonus' Movies
7 hours ago
iPhone 18 Pro Colors Buyer's Guide: Which Should You Choose?
iPhone 18 Pro Colors Buyer's Guide: Which Should You Choose?
7 hours ago
Early Prime Big Deal Days: Best Discounts on Accessories, TVs, and More at Amazon
Early Prime Big Deal Days: Best Discounts on Accessories, TVs, and More at Amazon
7 hours ago
MacBook Pro With OLED Touch Screen Rumored to Launch in October or November
MacBook Pro With OLED Touch Screen Rumored to Launch in October or November
9 hours ago
Apple's All-New Home Hub Rumored to Launch in These Four Colors
Apple's All-New Home Hub Rumored to Launch in These Four Colors
9 hours ago
iPhone 18 Pro Aperture Control Goes Fully Manual in Halide 3.2
iPhone 18 Pro Aperture Control Goes Fully Manual in Halide 3.2
10 hours ago
Apple Stores Receive 'Do Not Open' Boxes Ahead of Smart Home Products Launch
Apple Stores Receive 'Do Not Open' Boxes Ahead of Smart Home Products Launch
11 hours ago
iPhone 18 Pro Sales Jump in China Ahead of iPhone Duo Launch
iPhone 18 Pro Sales Jump in China Ahead of iPhone Duo Launch
12 hours ago
Apple TV Still Down for Some Users Following Apple Services Outage
Apple TV Still Down for Some Users Following Apple Services Outage
12 hours ago
PSA: Apple Mail on Mac May Stop Syncing Microsoft 365 Accounts Today
PSA: Apple Mail on Mac May Stop Syncing Microsoft 365 Accounts Today
13 hours ago
Apple's Smart Home Hub: Everything We Know So Far
Apple's Smart Home Hub: Everything We Know So Far
23 hours ago
Apple's Home Hub Borrows From the iPhone Duo's StandBy Mode
Apple's Home Hub Borrows From the iPhone Duo's StandBy Mode
1 day ago
Apple Invites App Updated With Three New Features
Apple Invites App Updated With Three New Features
1 day ago
Apple Event on October 13?
Apple Event on October 13?
1 day ago
Apple Watch SE 3 vs. Series 12 Buyer's Guide: Which Should You Buy?
Apple Watch SE 3 vs. Series 12 Buyer's Guide: Which Should You Buy?
1 day ago
iPad Mini 8 to Offer These 10 New Features
iPad Mini 8 to Offer These 10 New Features
1 day ago
DoorDash Unveils AI Food Ordering Through Apple's Messages App
DoorDash Unveils AI Food Ordering Through Apple's Messages App
1 day ago
Amazon Takes Up to $150 Off Select M5 MacBook Air Models
Amazon Takes Up to $150 Off Select M5 MacBook Air Models
1 day ago
Apple Still Plans to Release a New Full-Sized HomePod
Apple Still Plans to Release a New Full-Sized HomePod
1 day ago
Apple Working to Expand HomeKit
Apple Working to Expand HomeKit
1 day ago
Apple Smart Home Hub to Feature iMac G4-Style Design
Apple Smart Home Hub to Feature iMac G4-Style Design
2 days ago
Three New Apple Smart Home Products Coming on October 13
Three New Apple Smart Home Products Coming on October 13
2 days ago
Apple Pay Now Available in India With Axis Bank Cards
Apple Pay Now Available in India With Axis Bank Cards
2 days ago
OpenAI Launches Always-On 'Dots' Agents to Rival Meta's Muse
OpenAI Launches Always-On 'Dots' Agents to Rival Meta's Muse
2 days ago
AirPods 5 Teardown: Batteries Removable, Case Still Tough
AirPods 5 Teardown: Batteries Removable, Case Still Tough
2 days ago
iPhone 18 Pro Owners Complain of Speaker Crackling or Popping
iPhone 18 Pro Owners Complain of Speaker Crackling or Popping
2 days ago

🔗 Related Apple News & Rumors

Stay updated with the latest Apple ecosystem news and verified rumors